Hey all,as promised here is my second review of the night for none other than the hot off the screen new Harry Potter,which I viewed at a sold out performance last night.Enjoy.
Well first off,I was a bit dissapointed. Here's why.
Firstly,the pacing was off and it felt like they included too much from the first part of the book and not enough from the second,and in my opinion better,half. Continously the film felt as though it was building towards events that ultimately never happened as it moved on to building to the next anticlimax.
Secondly,and I said I wouldn't bitch about this because I feel they should be viewed seperately but you have to compare the book and film to a certain extent,they missed out too much.Like really.The Order of the Phoenix was pretty bad for changing stuff but this one just went all out.Dumbledore's funeral was one of the most moving scenes in all seven of the books and they didn't have it,instead replacing it with some cheesy 'lets all shove our wands in the air' simultaneous action.To me,the fight at Hogwarts at the end of the sixth book would have made for some stunning film footage if they'd shot it right,and I was really looking forward to seeing it play out,with Snape killing Dumbledore being a climax.Instead,it doesn't even happen,making the presence of the death eaters in Hogwarts actually completely inexplicable if Malfoy was meant to be killing Dumbledore,and the end of the film seem like a complete anticlimax.Also,they made a mistake in missing out the fact that Dumbledore paralyses Harry because if the Harry on screen had been the Harry Potter of the books who goes in fighting all the time,he would have stepped in instead of watching as a gang of death eaters clearly geared themselves up to murder his beloved Dumbledore.Grr,too many innacuracies for my fan girl likings.
My last complaint is that some parts seemed to me as though if you hadn't read the books you wouldn't get them.Perhaps they were there only to please fans of the books,who Warner Brothers so royally pissed off by pushing back the release date.But I doubt it.One example of this is when Harry is speaking to Proffessor McGonnagal about getting to sit potions and she's listing off the exam types and the grades etc.If you hadn't read the books,you wouldn't have understood what on earth they were talking about,seen as how OWL's were barely mentioned in the fifth film.However I did KIND OF like the arrogant attitude that they've taken,assuming that no character needs an introduction and that their audience knows whats happening.Whilst this is probably for the most part applicable and true,there will be some first timers amongst the audience and I really feel that for them this latest installment will be entirely foreign and pretty much unintelligable.
Now,the good parts,and the stuff that actually made me like it despite my dissapointment.
Firstly,acting has improved all around.Where in the past I've found Michael Gambon's portrayal of Dumbledore to be very different from the kind hearted old man we see in the books,I finally seen some more Dumbledoresque things about him - the knitting patterns bit being delivered exquisately for example. I have high hopes for his portrayal of a younger Dumbledore in films 7/8. Dan Radcliffe has certainly improved,I'd put that down to Equus.Rupert Grint had always been my favourite of the three leads in terms of acting capability but this time around he really gets his teeth into the humour and we get a glance of him in his comfort zone I think.Emma Watson still doesn't really do it for me as Hermoine,but she's not terrible.Helena Bonham Carter delieverd a chilling performance as Bellatrix, amping it up from the nutter we saw last time around.I was a bit uncomfortable with her strangely sexualised attitude towards Draco though...Speaking of,Tom Felton really did steal the show.He's been perfect for Malfoy since the very beginning,but this film really did allow him to step up to the mark I always knew he was capable of and he blew me away as the troubled and scared,highly pressured Malfoy.
Secondly,the humour was great giving it a bit of a lighter tone in comparison to the previous two installments.Less angst and more of the fun you need for a summer film. The overuse of the word snogging did get on my nerves though.
Third off the romantic elements were dealt with nicely,and not as in your face as the Harry-Cho set up of Goblet of Fire and Order of the Phoenix. The scene after Lavender first kisses Ron,when Harry finds Hermoine upset,was really very moving.Watson still annoyed me,but it was touching.
Fourth the muisc was great.But then again it's always been good in the Potter films.My favourite piece was what appears to be Harry and Ginny's theme.Very beautiful and it relfects the relationship we see portrayed in the books very well.
Finally,whilst I bitched up above about the cutting out of stuff,where they added parts I did like them.For example the Burrow getting burnt down almost reduced me to tears.That's probably because I know the Weasley family and all that the Burrow represents,and it just saddenned me to see it up in flames like that.
Other things that I liked about this film include Luna's Gryffindor Lion headpiece - so awesome! The inclusion of the Pigmy Puff and how Luna couldn't take her eyes off it on the train. The way the Slug Club was dealt with. The inclusion of minor characters such as Cormac,Blaise and the other Slytherin's that Malfoy hangs around with (I can't remember their names). The inlclusion of the 'Malfoy Stomps on Harry and Hides Him' scene on the train. Dumbledore's visit to the Orphanage. The performance of the young Tom Riddle. The scene in the cave - Gambon was very good here particularly. And the end when Fawkes flew away was pretty moving aswell.
Overall,I did enjoy this film,but not as much as I'd hoped to.It had the potential to be a lot better and I feel like the ending didn't quite leave me as anxious about what was going to happen in the seventh and eighth films as the ending of the book left me wondering about the seventh book.However,it wasn't a bad night out and I'm sure I'll probably see it again.Don't compare it to the book and it's a good enough magic movie.But of course that is impossible to do and when compared to its literary counter part,it really does fall short.
Overall I'd say 7/10. Not my film of the summer,but worth a watch.
Your Thoughts?
Until Next Time